In 1993 a British based charity (International
Integrated Health Association IIHA) made contact and was able to
initiate a very productive collaborative programme which still
continues.
Initially the collaborative programme was based on a
"twinning" with the cystic fibrosis centre in Southampton which was of
comparative size in terms of patients. It was immediately recognised
that cystic fibrosis care in the UK could not be absolutely paralleled
in Russia because of the sheer resource implications. For example in
the UK at that time the average patient with cystic fibrosis cost the
National Health Services about 15 000 USD per year. That type of
resource would not be available in Russia and would not even be
appropriate in the Russian setting. With the help of a pharmaceutical
company (Solvay) a project was set up to see whether a much smaller
investment in Moscow could produce results that might at least be
comparable. The end point in a 4 year project was to prove that perhaps
90% of the benefit seen in the UK could be obtained in Russia with less
than 10% of the resources. This was not only extremely good news in the
Russian setting but was also very important information in the UK where
it was recognised that a lot of the additional expenditure was probably
unnecessary. The results of that collaborative study have now been
published. The essence of the modified clinical approach was based on
the knowledge that the Moscow team had good training and expertise and
that the British team had practical experience in the running of a
clinical service.
One of the first changes in Moscow was the
development of an outpatient service. This meant that children were not
only seen when they were ill (and were usually admitted to hospital)
but children were seen when they were well in order to keep them well
and keep them out of hospital. At regular outpatient visits children
were carefully weighed and measured and this data was carefully
recorded on individual growth charts. With a condition such as cystic
fibrosis it is very easy to see quickly if something is going wrong,
perhaps before the patients or the parents are aware of this. As a
result, children's' use of hospital inpatient facilities was
drastically reduced. There was, therefore, a change in the whole way in
which the doctors worked. They now saw more children, but in an
ambulatory context, and the number of beds occupied by children in the
hospital was reduced from about 30 beds at any one time down to as few
as 4 or 6.
An unexpected complication of this improvement
centered on the fact that funding was based on bed occupancy. At first
sight there could be a great reduction in the budget although the
service required the same budget in order to run an outpatient or
ambulatory service. These issues were to some degree overcome.
Twinning involved virtually all the staff of the
cystic fibrosis service in Moscow. Doctors, nurses, laboratory staff
and clerical staff all had the opportunity to visit the clinic in
Southampton and conversely the Southampton staff, including medical,
paramedical and secretarial staff, visited Moscow. Throughout the
exchange process staff stayed with local families in order to get to
know them as people and understand their lifestyles and the problems
and benefits of living in each country. This was seen as much more
beneficial than for example the expensive use of limited resources
simply to attend conferences.
One example of such an exchange was that involving
the secretary for the CF Service in Southampton, who had a great deal
of experience in the way in which notes could be set out and filed and
records of phone numbers and important contacts could be held. This
secretary exchanged with her counterpart in Moscow and they were able
to discuss the ways in which the traditional Russian handling of
patients did not always make quick access to data easy. Simply using a
Western style filing system with growth charts enormously improved
communication and continuity of record keeping. The cost of this was
within 1 USD per patient.
It may come as a surprise to outside observers that
as a result of this collaboration the cost of antibiotics for cystic
fibrosis care in Moscow has actually gone down while the growth and
development of the children has improved to the point where the height
and weight and wellbeing of the Moscow cystic fibrosis children closely
matches those of children with CF in the UK. Most of the children are
now attending school and because the children are well enough the
mothers are often able to go back to work which was not the case in the
early development of the services. Some children are having home IV
therapy supervised by the specialist CF nurse.
Although detailed calculations have not been made it
is recognised in the west that patients with cystic fibrosis do not
usually die in childhood. Given the improved well being of Russian
children with CF it is probably also the case now that a newly
diagnosed patient, with good care, will probably live into early or
middle adult life.
The Moscow CF Team involves hospital medical staff
as well as academic university staff and research is an essential part
of the enthusiastic combined service. Many projects have been carried
out and many are in progress. Presentations at national and
international conferences are now routine.
As the cystic fibrosis team in Moscow has
consolidated its service it has also been able to improve other aspects
of the well being of children in hospital. They have a beautiful
brightly coloured ward with pictures and toys and an atmosphere where
children are happy and their parents feel confident. Not only has this
transformation occurred locally in the Republican Hospital but also it
has now spread to the emerging cystic fibrosis clinics in over 20 other
cities throughout Russia
The Russian- Southampton CF collaboration has
triggered twinning between other paediatric departments in Moscow and
Southampton notably between the surgical and diabetic departments.
Other CF twinnings on a smaller scale have been set up between Omsk and
Novosibersk and Poole and Portsmouth in the UK. In addition Southampton
has effectively used the same model in Albania and India.
Professor Kapranov and his dedicated team should be
very proud of the success of their service. The struggle of the early
years has paid off abundantly. They now have an internationally
recognized service of excellence which is of benefit to children with
cystic fibrosis throughout Russia and provides a model of good
childcare which could provide lessons for any developing paediatric
service.
Источник: http://www.mucoviscidos.ru/doctors/article.asp?id=1857 |